Free Decision Guide · PDF

3PL vs in-house fulfillment: when to switch.

Is your own floor still cheaper than a 3PL once rent, labor, packaging and your hours are counted?

300+
orders/month — the usual trigger
20–30%
typical total-cost savings
5
factors that decide it
4–6 wks
typical transition

Get the decision guide

Instant PDF with the 5-factor scoring framework.
Free. No sales sequence attached.
What's inside

Count every cost — then decide with numbers, not nerves.

True-cost worksheet

Rent, labor, packaging, carriers, software, insurance, equipment, utilities — and the line most owners skip: their own time at their real hourly value.

The five-factor framework

Volume, growth trajectory, product profile, geography and management bandwidth — scored so the answer is obvious instead of argued.

Transition roadmap

Week-by-week: SKU setup, integration, inbound, test orders, go-live — what it costs, how long it takes, and what to expect at each phase.

⏱️ Get your week back

Running fulfillment eats 15–30 hours a week. That's a marketing hire you're not making.

📈 Scale without building

100 to 10,000 orders a month without a lease, a forklift or a hiring spree.

🚚 Better carrier rates

Volume-negotiated rates typically 15–25% below what you can get alone.

🎯 Focus on growth

Product, marketing and customers — instead of tape guns and dock schedules.

Quick self-check

Three or more of these and you've outgrown in-house.

Run the cost calculator → Get a real quote
Inside the guide — the numbers

The real cost of in-house, at 500 orders a month.

Most brands count rent and labor and stop. The full list is longer — and the line most founders skip is their own time.

In-house cost categoryMonthlyAnnual
Warehouse rent (2,000 sq ft)$2,500 – $5,000$30,000 – $60,000
Labor (1–2 part-time workers)$3,000 – $6,000$36,000 – $72,000
Packaging materials$500 – $1,500$6,000 – $18,000
Shipping software / labels$100 – $300$1,200 – $3,600
Insurance$200 – $500$2,400 – $6,000
Equipment / maintenance$200 – $500$2,400 – $6,000
Utilities$300 – $600$3,600 – $7,200
Your time (opportunity cost)$2,000 – $5,000$24,000 – $60,000
Total (excluding carrier charges)$8,800 – $19,400$105,600 – $232,800
Typical 3PL at 500 orders/monthRateMonthly
Receiving$5 – $20 / pallet$100 – $500
Storage$10 – $25 / pallet / mo (GSW: $10–$25 SC · $15–$30 CA)$200 – $750
Pick & pack$1.20 – $5.00 / order$600 – $2,500
Account managementFlat fee$0 – $500
WMS / software access & integrationsFlat fee$0 – $300
Total (excluding shipping, which you pay either way)$900 – $4,550
The comparison: $900–$4,550 a month for a 3PL versus $6,800–$14,400 a month in-house (both excluding shipping, and before counting your own hours, which add another $2,000–$5,000 to the in-house side). For most brands the math starts favoring a 3PL between 200 and 500 orders a month.

The 5-factor framework — score each 1 to 5

1 · Volume consistency

5 if you ship 300+ orders a month consistently; 1 if under 50. 3PLs run best on predictable demand.

2 · Growth trajectory

5 if you're growing 20%+ month over month and can't keep up; 1 if volume is stable. Rapid growth breaks in-house fast.

3 · Time allocation

5 if you or your team spend 20+ hours a week on fulfillment; 1 if under 5. That's opportunity cost you're burning.

4 · Shipping complexity

5 if you're multi-channel (DTC + Amazon + wholesale), need same-day ship, or handle oversized product; 1 if single-channel standard parcels.

5 · Geographic reach

5 if customers are nationwide and speed matters competitively; 1 if mostly local. Bi-coastal cuts both transit time and cost.

Add it up

Your five scores total 5–25. The bands below tell you what to do next.

20–25

A 3PL is a clear win. Start evaluating partners now.

13–19

You're at the tipping point. Start conversations and compare real quotes to your current costs.

5–12

In-house is likely still your best option. Revisit in six months.

What the transition actually looks like

WeekMilestoneWhat happens
1–2Discovery & quoting3PL learns your products, volumes and requirements
2–3Technology setupWMS integration with your sales channels
3–4Inventory transferShip or deliver inventory to the 3PL
4Receiving & putawayCounted, verified and shelved
5Parallel testingRun orders through the 3PL while monitoring quality
6+Full go-liveAll orders routing through the 3PL

Most brands are fully transitioned in 4–6 weeks. The variable is whether the 3PL has a structured onboarding process — GSW's typically runs under a week thanks to our own integration layer, and we test before a single live order moves.

Also free

Other tools shippers use before choosing a 3PL.